How to say Must not do and Cannot continue to do in Japanese
1. Introduce about 「てはいけない」and 「てはいられない」
✅ Similarities:
- Both structures include 「ては」 and are somewhat related to restrictions or inability to continue an action.
✅ Main Differences:
Expression | Meaning & Nuance | Usage |
---|---|---|
「てはいけない」 | “Must not do A” (Prohibition, restriction, rules) | Used to express rules, moral constraints, or prohibitions |
「てはいられない」 | “Cannot continue A” (Due to urgency or necessity) | Used to express that one cannot continue an action due to external circumstances or personal determination |
2.「てはいけない」: Prohibition
✅ Structure:
Vて + はいけない
✅ Meaning:
- Indicates prohibition or restriction, meaning “must not do A”.
- Stronger than “だめ” (dame) and more formal.
- Used in laws, rules, commands, and societal regulations.
✅ 📌 Example Sentences:
- 「ここでタバコを吸ってはいけません。」
(You must not smoke here.)
→ (A rule or restriction.) - 「夜遅くまでゲームをしてはいけません。」
(You must not play games until late at night.)
→ (A parental rule or restriction.) - 「授業中に携帯を使ってはいけない。」
(You must not use your phone during class.)
→ (A school rule or disciplinary measure.)
✅ 📌 Usage Contexts:
- Laws & Regulations: 「車は赤信号で進んではいけません。」(You must not proceed when the traffic light is red.)
- Social Norms: 「他人のものを勝手に使ってはいけない。」(You must not use other people’s belongings without permission.)
- School & Work Rules: 「仕事中に私用電話をかけてはいけません。」(You must not make personal calls during work.)
3.「てはいられない」: Inability to Continue an Action
✅ Structure:
Vて + はいられない
✅ Meaning:
- Indicates that one “cannot afford to continue doing A”.
- Can be used for both external situations (time constraints, urgency) and personal will (determination).
- Emphasizes that continuing the action is no longer possible.
✅ 📌 Example Sentences:
- 「のんびりしてはいられない。」
(I can’t afford to be relaxed.)
→ (The situation demands action.) - 「もう待ってはいられない。」
(I can’t wait any longer!)
→ (Indicates frustration or urgency.) - 「試験が近いので、遊んではいられない。」
(The exam is approaching, so I can’t keep playing.)
→ (Indicates necessity to focus on studies.)
✅ 📌 Usage Contexts:
- Urgent Situations: 「こんな状況では安心してはいられない。」(In this situation, I can’t afford to feel at ease.)
- Time Constraints: 「時間がないので、ゆっくりしてはいられない。」(There’s no time, so I can’t take it easy.)
- Personal Determination: 「いつまでも親に頼ってはいられない。」(I can’t keep relying on my parents forever.)
4. Can “てはいけない” and “てはいられない” Be Used Interchangeably?
✅ They CANNOT be directly interchanged because their functions are entirely different:
Sentence | Can It Be Replaced? | Reason |
---|---|---|
「ここでタバコを吸ってはいけません。」 | ❌ 「ここでタバコを吸ってはいられません。」 | “てはいけない” means prohibition, while “てはいられない” would mean “I can’t resist smoking,” which changes the meaning. |
「試験が近いので、遊んではいられない。」 | ❌ 「試験が近いので、遊んではいけない。」 | “てはいられない” expresses subjective urgency, while “てはいけない” would mean a strict rule against playing. |
「こんな状況では安心してはいられない。」 | ❌ 「こんな状況では安心してはいけない。」 | “てはいられない” means “I can’t stay relaxed,” while “てはいけない” would mean “it is forbidden to be relaxed,” which is unnatural. |
📌 Summary:
- 「てはいけない」 = External prohibition (rules, laws, instructions).
- 「てはいられない」 = Subjective inability to continue (urgency, pressure, determination).
5. Which One Appears More in JLPT N2/N3?
✅ 「てはいけない」 → N4 / N3 Grammar (Basic Rules & Prohibition)
- Common in N4/N3 exams, mainly in grammar and reading comprehension.
- Used in daily life, school rules, company policies, and general prohibitions.
✅ 「てはいられない」 → N2 Grammar (More Advanced Usage)
- Common in N2 exams, especially in reading comprehension and writing.
- Frequently appears in scenarios involving urgency, time constraints, and personal decisions.
- Often tested alongside「〜ていられない」「〜ていられなくなる」.
📌 JLPT Exam Frequency
Grammar | JLPT Level | Exam Frequency |
---|---|---|
「てはいけない」 | N3 / N4 | 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟(Very High) |
「てはいられない」 | N2 | 🌟🌟🌟🌟(High) |
6. Summary
Grammar | Meaning | Usage | JLPT Level |
---|---|---|---|
「てはいけない」 | “Must not do” (Prohibition) | Rules, laws, instructions | N3 / N4 |
「てはいられない」 | “Cannot continue A” (Urgency, necessity) | Time constraints, determination | N2 |
💡 How to Choose? ✅ If it’s about prohibition, rules, or restrictions → Use「てはいけない」
✅ If it’s about not being able to continue an action due to circumstances or determination → Use「てはいられない」
7. 🎯 Practice Questions
- 「明日は試験があるので、今日は遊ん______。」
(Tomorrow is the exam, so I can’t keep playing today.)- A. てはいられない
- B. てはいけない
- ✅ Correct Answer: A (indicating “I can’t keep playing” due to urgency.)
- 「学校のルールでは、教室でスマホを使っ______。」
(According to school rules, you must not use a smartphone in the classroom.)- A. てはいられない
- B. てはいけない
- ✅ Correct Answer: B (expressing a strict rule.)
© Copyright notes
The copyright of the article belongs to the author, please do not reprint without permission.
Related posts
No comments...